I debated with myself for a long time over the 857 or 817 choice
got the 817 first in an error...
got the 857 much later because that is what I wanted in the first place
now many many years later
the 817 runs perfect, my 857 is broken, no one can here me on HF at all, they say it sounds like RF feedback to the microphone. and that is not it at all as I have tested it
the idle current gets messed up in the finals of each of the radios, so after time you have to go calibrate them again
I did this for each of them and did it for my version of the radio
still did not fix the 857 (other than on 2M ssb)
now I can listen to myself and here perfect audio from the 857 on HF, but 50 miles away no one can copy me.
so after I came to terms with the 857 failure I had my FT2900 fail on me, it was a filter.
turns out that they put DC voltage on filters that the specifications say you should not be doing
and it was not just the FT2900 or the 857, it was also the 817 and the VX-3
so out of 5 radios from them (2 were the same), I have one that still works
was likely blind luck that my 817 is the one still running
even talked to a representative about this at the visalia DX convention and they said they knew about the issue and that the engineering department had been told and seemed not to care.
so my suggestion to others is give up on the 817 VS the 857 question and move on to any other brand
my alinco dx77 is the only thing that seems to make contacts on lately, and I find that sad because it was suppose to be some low end junk, yet it has been perfect through the test of time.
go look at the schematics and see if your radio puts DC voltage on your IF filters